Home > Zip: > City: >
MLS# 2700828R Status: Active

21 Elm Place, Milltown NJ 08850

Milltown, NJ 08850

$674,000

  • Sq. Ft.

    1,874

  • Beds

    3

  • Baths

    1.50

  • Year Built

    1938

  • Garage

    1

  • Pool

    No

Step into the timeless charm of this one-of-a-kind custom-built 1923 Colonial, offering classic character and endless potential. The first floor features a welcoming living room with a fireplace, a cozy sitting room, formal dining room, spacious eat-in country kitchen, convenient powder room, and a screened-in porch perfect for relaxing and enjoying the peaceful surroundings. The second floor offers three generously sized bedrooms, two of which feature their own private sitting rooms, providing flexible space for a home office, reading nook, or nursery. Stairs access to the expansive attic presents an excellent opportunity to create a luxurious primary suite, guest quarters, or additional living space. A picturesque backyard that gently slopes to Farrington Lake, where you can launch your canoe or kayak and enjoy waterfront living right from your own property. Ideally located near major highways, NJ Transit, bus lines, and Newark Liberty International Airport, this home also offers easy access to downtown New Brunswick's acclaimed restaurants, theaters, and entertainment. Minutes from Rutgers University, Robert Wood Johnson University Hospital, and Saint Peter's University Hospital, all while enjoying the charm and close-knit community of desirable Milltown. A truly special property combining historic character, scenic beauty, and an unbeatable location.

Courtesy of RE/MAX COUNTRY

Listing Price
$649,900
Jul 15, 2026
Current Price
$674,000
22 days on market
 
Jul 16, 2026 (1 days listed)
Price increased to $699,000.
 
Jul 16, 2026 (1 days listed)
Listing office changed from to RE/MAX COUNTRY.
 
Jul 17, 2026 (2 days listed)
Status changed to active.
 
Jul 17, 2026 (2 days listed)
Listing office changed from RE/MAX COUNTRY to .
 
Jul 17, 2026 (2 days listed)
Price reduced to $699,000.
 
Jul 17, 2026 (2 days listed)
Listing office changed from to RE/MAX COUNTRY.
 
Jul 17, 2026 (3 days listed)
Price reduced to $699,000.
 
Jul 17, 2026 (3 days listed)
Listing office changed from RE/MAX COUNTRY to .
 
Jul 17, 2026 (3 days listed)
Price reduced to $699,000.
 
Jul 17, 2026 (3 days listed)
Listing office changed from to RE/MAX COUNTRY.
 
Jul 17, 2026 (3 days listed)
Listing office changed from RE/MAX COUNTRY to .
 
Jul 17, 2026 (3 days listed)
Listing office changed from to RE/MAX COUNTRY.
 
Jul 17, 2026 (3 days listed)
Listing office changed from RE/MAX COUNTRY to .
 
Jul 17, 2026 (3 days listed)
Listing office changed from to RE/MAX COUNTRY.
 
Jul 18, 2026 (3 days listed)
Listing office changed from RE/MAX COUNTRY to .
 
Jul 18, 2026 (3 days listed)
Listing office changed from to RE/MAX COUNTRY.
 
Jul 18, 2026 (3 days listed)
Listing office changed from RE/MAX COUNTRY to .
 
Jul 18, 2026 (3 days listed)
Listing office changed from to RE/MAX COUNTRY.
 
Jul 18, 2026 (3 days listed)
Listing office changed from RE/MAX COUNTRY to .
 
Jul 18, 2026 (3 days listed)
Listing office changed from to RE/MAX COUNTRY.
 
Jul 18, 2026 (3 days listed)
Listing office changed from RE/MAX COUNTRY to .
 
Jul 18, 2026 (3 days listed)
Listing office changed from to RE/MAX COUNTRY.
 
Jul 18, 2026 (3 days listed)
Listing office changed from RE/MAX COUNTRY to .
 
Jul 18, 2026 (3 days listed)
Listing office changed from to RE/MAX COUNTRY.
 
Jul 18, 2026 (3 days listed)
Listing office changed from RE/MAX COUNTRY to .
 
Jul 18, 2026 (3 days listed)
Listing office changed from to RE/MAX COUNTRY.
 
Jul 27, 2026 (12 days listed)
Listing office changed from RE/MAX COUNTRY to .
 
Jul 27, 2026 (12 days listed)
Listing office changed from to RE/MAX COUNTRY.
 
Jul 27, 2026 (12 days listed)
Listing office changed from RE/MAX COUNTRY to .
 
Jul 27, 2026 (12 days listed)
Listing office changed from to RE/MAX COUNTRY.
 
Jul 27, 2026 (12 days listed)
Price reduced to $674,000.
 
Jul 27, 2026 (12 days listed)
Price increased to $699,000.
 
Jul 31, 2026 (16 days listed)
Listing office changed from RE/MAX COUNTRY to .
 
Jul 31, 2026 (16 days listed)
Listing office changed from to RE/MAX COUNTRY.
 
Jul 31, 2026 (16 days listed)
Listing office changed from RE/MAX COUNTRY to .
 
Jul 31, 2026 (16 days listed)
Listing office changed from to RE/MAX COUNTRY.
 
Jul 31, 2026 (16 days listed)
Listing office changed from RE/MAX COUNTRY to .
 
Aug 3, 2026 (19 days listed)
Listing office changed from to RE/MAX COUNTRY.
 
Aug 3, 2026 (19 days listed)
Listing office changed from RE/MAX COUNTRY to .
 
Aug 3, 2026 (19 days listed)
Listing office changed from to RE/MAX COUNTRY.
 
Aug 3, 2026 (19 days listed)
Listing office changed from RE/MAX COUNTRY to .
 
Aug 3, 2026 (19 days listed)
Listing office changed from to RE/MAX COUNTRY.
 
Aug 3, 2026 (19 days listed)
Listing office changed from RE/MAX COUNTRY to .
Price Per Sq Ft - $359.66
Date
08/03/2026
Status
Price
$674,000
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$359.66
Source
Date
08/03/2026
Status
Active
Price
$674,000
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$359.66
Source
RE/MAX COUNTRY
Date
08/03/2026
Status
Price
$674,000
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$359.66
Source
Date
08/03/2026
Status
Active
Price
$674,000
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$359.66
Source
RE/MAX COUNTRY
Date
08/03/2026
Status
Price
$674,000
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$359.66
Source
Date
08/03/2026
Status
Active
Price
$674,000
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$359.66
Source
RE/MAX COUNTRY
Date
07/31/2026
Status
Price
$674,000
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$359.66
Source
Date
07/31/2026
Status
Active
Price
$674,000
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$359.66
Source
RE/MAX COUNTRY
Date
07/31/2026
Status
Price
$674,000
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$359.66
Source
Date
07/31/2026
Status
Active
Price
$674,000
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$359.66
Source
RE/MAX COUNTRY
Date
07/31/2026
Status
Price
$674,000
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$359.66
Source
Date
07/27/2026
Status
Active
Price
$699,000
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$373
Source
RE/MAX COUNTRY
Date
07/27/2026
Status
Price
$674,000
% Change
-3.6%
$ / sqft
$359.66
Source
Date
07/27/2026
Status
Active
Price
$674,000
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$359.66
Source
RE/MAX COUNTRY
Date
07/27/2026
Status
Price
$674,000
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$359.66
Source
Date
07/27/2026
Status
Active
Price
$674,000
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$359.66
Source
RE/MAX COUNTRY
Date
07/27/2026
Status
Price
$674,000
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$359.66
Source
Date
07/18/2026
Status
Active
Price
$699,000
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$373
Source
RE/MAX COUNTRY
Date
07/18/2026
Status
Price
$699,000
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$373
Source
Date
07/18/2026
Status
Active
Price
$699,000
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$373
Source
RE/MAX COUNTRY
Date
07/18/2026
Status
Price
$699,000
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$373
Source
Date
07/18/2026
Status
Active
Price
$699,000
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$373
Source
RE/MAX COUNTRY
Date
07/18/2026
Status
Price
$699,000
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$373
Source
Date
07/18/2026
Status
Active
Price
$699,000
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$373
Source
RE/MAX COUNTRY
Date
07/18/2026
Status
Price
$699,000
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$373
Source
Date
07/18/2026
Status
Active
Price
$699,000
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$373
Source
RE/MAX COUNTRY
Date
07/18/2026
Status
Price
$699,000
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$373
Source
Date
07/18/2026
Status
Active
Price
$699,000
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$373
Source
RE/MAX COUNTRY
Date
07/18/2026
Status
Price
$699,000
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$373
Source
Date
07/17/2026
Status
Active
Price
$699,000
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$373
Source
RE/MAX COUNTRY
Date
07/17/2026
Status
Price
$699,000
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$373
Source
Date
07/17/2026
Status
Active
Price
$699,000
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$373
Source
RE/MAX COUNTRY
Date
07/17/2026
Status
Price
$699,000
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$373
Source
Date
07/17/2026
Status
Active
Price
$699,000
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$373
Source
RE/MAX COUNTRY
Date
07/17/2026
Status
Price
$699,000
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$373
Source
Date
07/17/2026
Status
Price
$699,000
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$373
Source
Date
07/17/2026
Status
Active
Price
$699,000
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$373
Source
RE/MAX COUNTRY
Date
07/17/2026
Status
Active
Price
$699,000
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$373
Source
RE/MAX COUNTRY
Date
07/17/2026
Status
Price
$699,000
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$373
Source
Date
07/17/2026
Status
Price
$699,000
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$373
Source
Date
07/17/2026
Status
Active
Price
$699,000
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$373
Source
RE/MAX COUNTRY
Date
07/16/2026
Status
Coming Soon
Price
$699,000
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$373
Source
RE/MAX COUNTRY
Date
07/16/2026
Status
Price
$699,000
% Change
7.6%
$ / sqft
$373
Source
Date
07/15/2026
Status
Coming Soon
Price
$649,900
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$346.8
Source
RE/MAX COUNTRY
 

Property Details

Interior Features: Cedar Closet(s), Entrance Foyer, Kitchen, Bath Half, Living Room, Other Room(s), Dining Room, 3 Bedrooms, Bath Main, Attic
Beds: 3
Baths: 1
Half Baths: 1
Total Number of Rooms: 11
Master Bedroom Features: Sitting Area
Dining Room Features: Formal Dining Room
Kitchen Features: Country Kitchen, Eat-in Kitchen
Appliances: Dishwasher, Dryer, Gas Range/Oven, Refrigerator, Range, Washer, Gas Water Heater
Has Fireplace: Yes
Number of Fireplaces: 1
Fireplace Features: Wood Burning
Has Heating: Yes
Heating: Radiant, Radiators-Hot Water
Cooling: Wall Unit(s), Window Unit(s)
Flooring: Ceramic Tile, Wood
Basement: Full, Exterior Entry, Storage Space, Laundry Facilities

Interior Details

Property Type: Residential
Property Class: Single Family Residence
Structure Type: Custom Home
Architectural Style: Colonial, Custom Home
Building Sq Ft: 1,874
Year Built: 1938
Stories: 2
Levels: Two
Is New Construction: No
Has Private Pool: No
Has Spa: No
Has View: No
Has Garage: Yes
Has Attached Garage: Yes
Garage Spaces: 1
Has Carport: No
Carport Spaces: 0
Covered Spaces: 1
Has Open Parking: Yes
Parking Features: 1 Car Width, Garage, Attached, Garage Door Opener
Total Parking Spaces: 0

Exterior Details

Lot Features: Near Train, Waterview, Wooded, Near Public Transit
Lot Size (Acres): 0.6093
Lot Area: 0.6093
Lot Dimensions: 320.00 x 80.00
Lot Size (Square Feet): 26,541
Exterior Features: Barbecue, Patio, Enclosed Porch(es), Sidewalk, Fencing/Wall, Yard
Fencing: Fencing/Wall
Roof: Slate
Patio and Porch Features: Patio, Enclosed
On Waterfront: No
Property Attached: No

Utilities / Green Energy Details

Utilities: Cable TV, Cable Connected, Electricity Connected, Natural Gas Connected
Gas: Natural Gas
Sewer: Public Sewer
Water Source: Public
# of Electric Meters: 0
# of Gas Meters: 0
# of Water Meters: 0

Community and Neighborhood Details

Community Features: Sidewalks

HOA and Financial Details

Tax Year: 2025
Annual Taxes: $14,076.00
Has Association: No
Association Fee: $0.00
Association Fee 2: $0.00
Association Fee 2 Frequency: Monthly
 
Veronica

Veronica Hary

Fox & Foxx Realty

(732) 642-9093
 Mobile: (732) 642-9093

  • Required fields are indicated by an asterisk (*)

Similar Listings

22 Desmet Avenue, Milltown NJ 08850
Milltown, NJ 08850
$825,000
View more details
  • SqFt.2,221
  • Beds4
  • Baths2+1½
  • Garage2
  • PoolNo
20 Nelson Drive, Milltown NJ 08850
Milltown, NJ 08850
$825,000
View more details
  • SqFt.2,290
  • Beds4
  • Baths3+1½
  • Garage2
  • PoolNo
6 Mary Court, Milltown NJ 08850
Milltown, NJ 08850
$825,000
View more details
  • SqFt.2,245
  • Beds4
  • Baths2+2½
  • Garage2
  • PoolNo
10 Weller Court, Milltown NJ 08850
Milltown, NJ 08850
$775,000
View more details
  • SqFt.2,100
  • Beds3
  • Baths2+2½
  • Garage2
  • PoolNo
Tap Here To Call Us! (732) 642-9093

Sign Up

Sign up to save this property to your favorites! It's free!
Already signed up? Log In