Home > Zip: > City: >
MLS# 2609618R Status: Active Under Contract

344 Middlesex Avenue, Metuchen NJ 08840

Metuchen, NJ 08840

$1,799,999

  • Sq. Ft.

    5,412

  • Beds

    6

  • Baths

    4.00

  • Year Built

    1929

  • Garage

    2

  • Pool

    No

A rare offering of historic significance and modern refinement, the distinguished Applegate House'' presents over 5,400 square feet of elegant living set on 1.33 acres of beautifully landscaped grounds overlooking Woodwild Park Reservation. Recognized on the New Jersey and National Registers of Historic Places, this exceptional residence seamlessly blends timeless architecture with thoughtfully curated upgrades. A grand foyer with a sweeping staircase sets the tone, complemented by newly installed hardwood flooring, intricate crown molding, and three fireplaces that add warmth and character throughout. The fully reimagined gourmet kitchen (2025) is a true showpiece, featuring top-of-the-line Thermador appliances, custom cabinetry, and sophisticated designer finishes. The home offers six spacious bedrooms and five baths, including two newly renovated spa-inspired bathrooms (2024) adorned with marble accents and distinctive hammered copper tub and sinks. Multiple living and entertaining spaces are enhanced by French doors and classic architectural details, creating a seamless flow for both everyday living and elegant gatherings. Outdoors, the estate transforms into a private retreat with multiple porches and patios, expansive second-floor decks, and professionally designed landscaping with full-property estate lighting (2023). The impressive 85,000-gallon saltwater pool, complete with a new heater (2022), provides a resort-style experience. A full basement with a half bath offers additional flexibility, while the separate, fully renovated two-bedroom guest housefeaturing a loft, central air, and in-unit washer/dryerpresents exceptional accommodations for guests or income potential. Rich in history yet thoughtfully updated for modern living, this extraordinary property offers a truly unique opportunity to own a landmark residence of enduring elegance.

Courtesy of WEICHERT CO REALTORS

Listing Price
$1,749,999
Jan 16, 2026
Current Price
$1,799,999
54 days on market
 
Jan 23, 2026 (7 days listed)
Listing office changed from WEICHERT CO REALTORS to .
 
Jan 23, 2026 (7 days listed)
Listing office changed from to WEICHERT CO REALTORS.
 
Jan 25, 2026 (9 days listed)
Price reduced to $1,749,999.
 
Jan 25, 2026 (9 days listed)
Listing office changed from WEICHERT CO REALTORS to .
 
Jan 26, 2026 (10 days listed)
Price reduced to $1,749,999.
 
Jan 26, 2026 (10 days listed)
Listing office changed from to WEICHERT CO REALTORS.
 
Jan 26, 2026 (10 days listed)
Price reduced to $1,749,999.
 
Jan 26, 2026 (10 days listed)
Price reduced to $1,749,999.
 
Jan 28, 2026 (12 days listed)
Price reduced to $1,749,999.
 
Jan 28, 2026 (12 days listed)
Listing office changed from WEICHERT CO REALTORS to .
 
Jan 28, 2026 (12 days listed)
Listing office changed from to WEICHERT CO REALTORS.
 
Mar 30, 2026 (73 days listed)
Price increased to $1,799,999.
 
Mar 30, 2026 (73 days listed)
Listing office changed from to WEICHERT CO REALTORS.
 
Mar 30, 2026 (73 days listed)
Price reduced to $1,799,999.
 
Mar 30, 2026 (73 days listed)
Listing office changed from to WEICHERT CO REALTORS.
 
Apr 1, 2026 (75 days listed)
Price increased to $1,799,999.
 
Apr 1, 2026 (75 days listed)
Listing office changed from to WEICHERT CO REALTORS.
 
Apr 1, 2026 (75 days listed)
Listing office changed from WEICHERT CO REALTORS to .
 
Apr 1, 2026 (75 days listed)
Listing office changed from to WEICHERT CO REALTORS.
 
Apr 1, 2026 (75 days listed)
Listing office changed from WEICHERT CO REALTORS to .
 
Apr 1, 2026 (75 days listed)
Listing office changed from to WEICHERT CO REALTORS.
 
Apr 1, 2026 (75 days listed)
Listing office changed from WEICHERT CO REALTORS to .
 
Apr 4, 2026 (78 days listed)
Listing office changed from to WEICHERT CO REALTORS.
 
Apr 4, 2026 (78 days listed)
Listing office changed from WEICHERT CO REALTORS to .
 
Apr 4, 2026 (78 days listed)
Listing office changed from to WEICHERT CO REALTORS.
 
Apr 4, 2026 (78 days listed)
Listing office changed from WEICHERT CO REALTORS to .
 
Apr 4, 2026 (78 days listed)
Listing office changed from to WEICHERT CO REALTORS.
 
Apr 4, 2026 (78 days listed)
Listing office changed from WEICHERT CO REALTORS to .
 
Apr 4, 2026 (78 days listed)
Listing office changed from to WEICHERT CO REALTORS.
 
Apr 4, 2026 (78 days listed)
Listing office changed from WEICHERT CO REALTORS to .
 
Apr 4, 2026 (78 days listed)
Listing office changed from to WEICHERT CO REALTORS.
 
Apr 4, 2026 (78 days listed)
Listing office changed from WEICHERT CO REALTORS to .
 
Apr 4, 2026 (78 days listed)
Listing office changed from to WEICHERT CO REALTORS.
 
Apr 4, 2026 (78 days listed)
Listing office changed from WEICHERT CO REALTORS to .
 
Apr 4, 2026 (78 days listed)
Listing office changed from to WEICHERT CO REALTORS.
 
Apr 4, 2026 (78 days listed)
Listing office changed from WEICHERT CO REALTORS to .
 
Apr 4, 2026 (78 days listed)
Listing office changed from to WEICHERT CO REALTORS.
 
Apr 4, 2026 (78 days listed)
Listing office changed from WEICHERT CO REALTORS to .
 
Apr 4, 2026 (78 days listed)
Listing office changed from to WEICHERT CO REALTORS.
 
Apr 4, 2026 (78 days listed)
Listing office changed from WEICHERT CO REALTORS to .
 
Apr 4, 2026 (78 days listed)
Listing office changed from to WEICHERT CO REALTORS.
 
Apr 4, 2026 (78 days listed)
Listing office changed from WEICHERT CO REALTORS to .
 
Apr 4, 2026 (78 days listed)
Listing office changed from to WEICHERT CO REALTORS.
 
Apr 4, 2026 (78 days listed)
Listing office changed from WEICHERT CO REALTORS to .
 
Apr 4, 2026 (78 days listed)
Listing office changed from to WEICHERT CO REALTORS.
 
Apr 4, 2026 (78 days listed)
Listing office changed from WEICHERT CO REALTORS to .
 
Apr 26, 2026 (100 days listed)
Listing office changed from to WEICHERT CO REALTORS.
 
Apr 26, 2026 (100 days listed)
Listing office changed from WEICHERT CO REALTORS to .
 
Apr 26, 2026 (100 days listed)
Listing office changed from to WEICHERT CO REALTORS.
 
Apr 26, 2026 (100 days listed)
Price reduced to $1,799,999.
 
Apr 26, 2026 (100 days listed)
Listing office changed from WEICHERT CO REALTORS to .
 
Apr 26, 2026 (100 days listed)
Price reduced to $1,799,999.
 
Apr 26, 2026 (100 days listed)
Price reduced to $1,799,999.
 
Apr 26, 2026 (100 days listed)
Listing office changed from to WEICHERT CO REALTORS.
 
Apr 26, 2026 (100 days listed)
Listing office changed from WEICHERT CO REALTORS to .
 
Apr 26, 2026 (100 days listed)
Price reduced to $1,799,999.
 
Apr 26, 2026 (100 days listed)
Listing office changed from to WEICHERT CO REALTORS.
 
Apr 26, 2026 (100 days listed)
Listing office changed from WEICHERT CO REALTORS to .
 
Apr 26, 2026 (100 days listed)
Listing office changed from to WEICHERT CO REALTORS.
 
Apr 26, 2026 (100 days listed)
Listing office changed from WEICHERT CO REALTORS to .
 
Apr 26, 2026 (100 days listed)
Price reduced to $1,799,999.
Price Per Sq Ft - $332.59
Date
04/26/2026
Status
Price
$1,799,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$332.59
Source
Date
04/26/2026
Status
Price
$1,799,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$332.59
Source
Date
04/26/2026
Status
Active Under Contract
Price
$1,799,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$332.59
Source
WEICHERT CO REALTORS
Date
04/26/2026
Status
Price
$1,799,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$332.59
Source
Date
04/26/2026
Status
Active Under Contract
Price
$1,799,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$332.59
Source
WEICHERT CO REALTORS
Date
04/26/2026
Status
Price
$1,799,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$332.59
Source
Date
04/26/2026
Status
Price
$1,799,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$332.59
Source
Date
04/26/2026
Status
Active Under Contract
Price
$1,799,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$332.59
Source
WEICHERT CO REALTORS
Date
04/26/2026
Status
Price
$1,799,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$332.59
Source
Date
04/26/2026
Status
Price
$1,799,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$332.59
Source
Date
04/26/2026
Status
Price
$1,799,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$332.59
Source
Date
04/26/2026
Status
Active Under Contract
Price
$1,799,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$332.59
Source
WEICHERT CO REALTORS
Date
04/26/2026
Status
Active Under Contract
Price
$1,799,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$332.59
Source
WEICHERT CO REALTORS
Date
04/26/2026
Status
Price
$1,799,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$332.59
Source
Date
04/26/2026
Status
Active Under Contract
Price
$1,799,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$332.59
Source
WEICHERT CO REALTORS
Date
04/04/2026
Status
Active
Price
$1,799,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$332.59
Source
Date
04/04/2026
Status
Price
$1,799,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$332.59
Source
WEICHERT CO REALTORS
Date
04/04/2026
Status
Active
Price
$1,799,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$332.59
Source
Date
04/04/2026
Status
Price
$1,799,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$332.59
Source
WEICHERT CO REALTORS
Date
04/04/2026
Status
Active
Price
$1,799,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$332.59
Source
Date
04/04/2026
Status
Price
$1,799,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$332.59
Source
WEICHERT CO REALTORS
Date
04/04/2026
Status
Active
Price
$1,799,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$332.59
Source
Date
04/04/2026
Status
Price
$1,799,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$332.59
Source
WEICHERT CO REALTORS
Date
04/04/2026
Status
Active
Price
$1,799,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$332.59
Source
Date
04/04/2026
Status
Price
$1,799,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$332.59
Source
WEICHERT CO REALTORS
Date
04/04/2026
Status
Active
Price
$1,799,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$332.59
Source
Date
04/04/2026
Status
Price
$1,799,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$332.59
Source
WEICHERT CO REALTORS
Date
04/04/2026
Status
Active
Price
$1,799,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$332.59
Source
Date
04/04/2026
Status
Price
$1,799,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$332.59
Source
WEICHERT CO REALTORS
Date
04/04/2026
Status
Active
Price
$1,799,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$332.59
Source
Date
04/04/2026
Status
Price
$1,799,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$332.59
Source
WEICHERT CO REALTORS
Date
04/04/2026
Status
Active
Price
$1,799,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$332.59
Source
Date
04/04/2026
Status
Price
$1,799,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$332.59
Source
WEICHERT CO REALTORS
Date
04/04/2026
Status
Active
Price
$1,799,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$332.59
Source
Date
04/04/2026
Status
Price
$1,799,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$332.59
Source
WEICHERT CO REALTORS
Date
04/04/2026
Status
Active
Price
$1,799,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$332.59
Source
Date
04/04/2026
Status
Price
$1,799,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$332.59
Source
WEICHERT CO REALTORS
Date
04/04/2026
Status
Active
Price
$1,799,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$332.59
Source
Date
04/04/2026
Status
Price
$1,799,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$332.59
Source
WEICHERT CO REALTORS
Date
04/01/2026
Status
Active
Price
$1,799,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$332.59
Source
Date
04/01/2026
Status
Price
$1,799,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$332.59
Source
WEICHERT CO REALTORS
Date
04/01/2026
Status
Active
Price
$1,799,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$332.59
Source
Date
04/01/2026
Status
Price
$1,799,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$332.59
Source
WEICHERT CO REALTORS
Date
04/01/2026
Status
Active
Price
$1,799,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$332.59
Source
Date
04/01/2026
Status
Price
$1,799,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$332.59
Source
WEICHERT CO REALTORS
Date
04/01/2026
Status
Active
Price
$1,799,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$332.59
Source
Date
03/30/2026
Status
Price
$1,749,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$323.36
Source
WEICHERT CO REALTORS
Date
03/30/2026
Status
Active
Price
$1,799,999
% Change
2.9%
$ / sqft
$332.59
Source
Date
03/30/2026
Status
Price
$1,799,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$332.59
Source
WEICHERT CO REALTORS
Date
03/30/2026
Status
Active
Price
$1,799,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$332.59
Source
Date
01/28/2026
Status
Price
$1,749,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$323.36
Source
WEICHERT CO REALTORS
Date
01/28/2026
Status
Active
Price
$1,749,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$323.36
Source
Date
01/28/2026
Status
Price
$1,749,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$323.36
Source
WEICHERT CO REALTORS
Date
01/26/2026
Status
Price
$1,749,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$323.36
Source
WEICHERT CO REALTORS
Date
01/26/2026
Status
Price
$1,749,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$323.36
Source
WEICHERT CO REALTORS
Date
01/26/2026
Status
Price
$1,749,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$323.36
Source
WEICHERT CO REALTORS
Date
01/26/2026
Status
Active
Price
$1,749,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$323.36
Source
Date
01/25/2026
Status
Active
Price
$1,749,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$323.36
Source
Date
01/25/2026
Status
Price
$1,749,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$323.36
Source
WEICHERT CO REALTORS
Date
01/23/2026
Status
Price
$1,749,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$323.36
Source
WEICHERT CO REALTORS
Date
01/23/2026
Status
Active
Price
$1,749,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$323.36
Source
Date
01/16/2026
Status
Coming Soon
Price
$1,749,999
% Change
--
$ / sqft
$323.36
Source
WEICHERT CO REALTORS
 

Property Details

Interior Features: 2nd Stairway to 2nd Level, Cedar Closet(s), Vaulted Ceiling(s), Entrance Foyer, Great Room, Kitchen, Bath Half, Living Room, Storage, Dining Room, Family Room, 4 Bedrooms, Laundry Room, Bath Full, Bath Main, 2 Bedrooms, Other Room(s)
Beds: 6
Baths: 3
Half Baths: 2
Total Number of Rooms: 12
Master Bedroom Features: Sitting Area, Dressing Room, Full Bath
Dining Room Features: Formal Dining Room
Kitchen Features: Granite/Corian Countertops, Kitchen Exhaust Fan, Kitchen Island, Pantry, Eat-in Kitchen
Appliances: Self Cleaning Oven, Dishwasher, Disposal, Gas Range/Oven, Exhaust Fan, Microwave, Refrigerator, Range, Oven, Kitchen Exhaust Fan, Gas Water Heater
Has Fireplace: Yes
Number of Fireplaces: 3
Fireplace Features: Wood Burning
Has Heating: Yes
Heating: Zoned, Baseboard, Radiant, Baseboard Hotwater
Cooling: Central Air, Ceiling Fan(s), Zoned
Flooring: Ceramic Tile, Marble, Wood
Basement: Partially Finished, Full, Bath Half, Daylight, Exterior Entry, Recreation Room, Storage Space, Interior Entry, Utility Room, Workshop

Interior Details

Property Type: Residential
Property Class: Single Family Residence
Structure Type: Custom Home
Architectural Style: Colonial, Custom Home, Extra House on Lot
Building Sq Ft: 5,412
Year Built: 1929
Stories: 4
Levels: Three Or More
Is New Construction: No
Has Private Pool: No
Pool Features: In Ground
Has Spa: No
Has View: No
Has Garage: Yes
Has Attached Garage: Yes
Garage Spaces: 2
Has Carport: No
Carport Spaces: 0
Covered Spaces: 2
Has Open Parking: Yes
Other Structures: Second Residence
Parking Features: Additional Parking, Asphalt, Circular Driveway, Garage, Attached, Built-In Garage, Detached, Driveway, On Site, Paved
Total Parking Spaces: 0

Exterior Details

Lot Features: Near Shopping, Near Train, Backs to Park Land
Lot Size (Acres): 1.3361
Lot Area: 1.3361
Lot Dimensions: 200.00 x 219.00
Lot Size (Square Feet): 58,201
Exterior Features: Lawn Sprinklers, Open Porch(es), Curbs, Deck, Patio, Fencing/Wall, Yard
Fencing: Fencing/Wall
Roof: Asphalt, Flat
Patio and Porch Features: Porch, Deck, Patio
On Waterfront: No
Property Attached: No

Utilities / Green Energy Details

Utilities: Electricity Connected, Natural Gas Connected
Gas: Natural Gas
Sewer: Public Sewer
Water Source: Public
# of Electric Meters: 0
# of Gas Meters: 0
# of Water Meters: 0

Community and Neighborhood Details

Community Features: Curbs

HOA and Financial Details

Tax Year: 2024
Annual Taxes: $28,585.00
Has Association: No
Association Fee: $0.00
Association Fee 2: $0.00
Association Fee 2 Frequency: Monthly
 
Veronica

Veronica Hary

Fox & Foxx Realty

(732) 642-9093
 Mobile: (732) 642-9093

  • Required fields are indicated by an asterisk (*)

Similar Listings

61 Hickory Street, Metuchen NJ 08840
Metuchen, NJ 08840
$2,239,000
View more details
  • SqFt.4,250
  • Beds5
  • Baths5+1½
  • Garage2
  • PoolNo
303 Grove Avenue, Metuchen NJ 08840
Metuchen, NJ 08840
$1,599,900
View more details
  • SqFt.4,727
  • Beds6
  • Baths5+1½
  • Garage2
  • PoolNo
241 E Chestnut Avenue, Metuchen NJ 08840
Metuchen, NJ 08840
$1,525,000
View more details
  • SqFt.4,500
  • Beds6
  • Baths5+1½
  • Garage3
  • PoolNo
Tap Here To Call Us! (732) 642-9093

Sign Up

Sign up to save this property to your favorites! It's free!
Already signed up? Log In